RIE

Don’t Just Do Something, Sit There: 7 Reasons We Make Time for Quiet Observation in Class

The dream of my life
Is to lie down by a slow river
And stare at the light in the trees–
To learn something by being nothing
A little while
but the rich
Lens of attention.
— Mary Oliver

A parent recently asked me, “Why is quiet observation a part of this class?” I’m so grateful they inquired because this is such an important part of RIE® Parent-Infant Guidance™ classes. Here are 7+ benefits that can come from carving out space for quiet observation.  

Built-In “Wants Nothing” Quality Time 

If you’re carving out regular time for “wants nothing” quality time at home throughout the week, I applaud you! I also recognize that it can feel like a big ask for overwhelmed parents tapped out from “wants something” quality time (aka caregiving), work inside and outside of the home, caring for additional children, and tending to your own needs and relationships. Creating space in class for observation automatically builds “wants nothing” quality time into your day. You don’t have to think about it or plan it, you just know there will be time set aside for this relationship-building practice. In Dear Parent: Caring for Infants with Respect, Magda Gerber reminds us, “When we help a child to feel secure, feel appreciated, feel that ‘somebody is deeply, truly interested in me,’ by the way we just look, the way we just listen, we influence that child’s whole personality, the way that child sees life.” 

An Opportunity to Hone Your Observation Skills  

(The children) have learned something about how to pay attention, by having attention paid to them.
— Ruth Anne Hammond

Observation is a key tenet of Magda Gerber’s Educaring® approach. Maybe there are some folks who can easily and skillfully attend to dynamic, competing stimuli (how anyone can get meaningful work done in a noisy cafe is beyond my comprehension) but I prefer providing focused attention when I can. I know that I will miss important things in a large, bustling group–nuances of body language, bids for attention, barely perceptible interactions between children, and so on. And this doesn’t even include listening and responding to parents’ words! A period of quiet observation (in addition to smaller classes, intentionally capped at 6 families) allows all of us to more easily notice these minute details. Just as I ask parents to pause, refrain from conversation and engaging in play with their child, and observe the children in the group during quiet observation, I will occasionally tell a child who is wanting my attention during a parent’s check-in, “I’m listening to your mama right now, I’ll be with you in a minute.” Both children and parents are deserving of attentive listening.

A Chance to Practice Single-Tasking 

In her excellent book How to Stop Losing Your Sh*t with Your Kids, Dr. Carla Naumburg outlines a few of the ways that multitasking interferes with our ability to parent the way we want. She explains that, “(multitasking) makes us more distracted and less attentive, it increases our anxiety, it makes us more likely we’ll miss important information and cues, and it makes us less efficient.” Since multitasking is the go-to for most parents of young children, it can be difficult to “downshift” and practice slowing down and attending to one thing at a time. Quiet observation offers time for just that! Much like a meditation practice where the breath may be your “object” of attention, during quiet observation you might focus on your child (or someone else’s child) as the object of your attention. You might get lost in the thoughts running through your mind before gently bringing yourself back and refocusing on your child. 

Supporting Play, Regulation, Peer Relationships, and Focus 

Young children can become quite dysregulated when their parents are otherwise distracted (on the phone, talking to a friend, etc.) It’s not rare for the quality of children’s play to change in class when parents begin their check-ins–the children’s volume often increases, and they might begin climbing on the parent, putting their face very close to their parent’s face, or interrupting in other (totally developmentally appropriate) ways. This is not to say that parents should be expected to give their children full attention every waking moment. However, offering children a reliable time when they know they will not need to compete for your attention is an incredibly special and supportive gift. RIE® Associate Ruth Anne Hammond explains, “To the children, it is a welcome relief not to have to spend any of their attention either screening out the general noise level of a bunch of adults talking and laughing or trying to understand what is being said.” During quiet observation children are able to concentrate more deeply on their play, whether alone or with one another, nurturing their emerging capacity for focused attention and emotional intelligence. 

Access to Hive Mind Awareness 

Occasionally parents will share something they noticed during the observation that not everyone else noticed. It’s not just that the quality of your attention deepens the more you practice observation, but you’re also able to benefit from the sharp eyes and ears of the others in the class. Watching videos of infants and toddlers with students of RIE® Foundations™ or in the community college courses I teach, I’m eternally astounded by the diversity of what students notice while watching the same exact video. What we see is impacted by a multitude of factors and this is the joy of the group! Seeing everything your child can do through the eyes of another can be enlightening and inspiring.

You (Literally) Get to Sit Back While I Intervene 

RIE® Parent Infant Guidance classes are designed to primarily be demonstration classes. Throughout the class, including during quiet observation, I will model supportive interactions (as necessary) with the children. There may be a conflict between children or an exploration to determine which play objects may be thrown. A child may need spotting on the climbing triangle, or they might become frustrated with a plan they had that isn’t working out as they’d hoped (e.g. dressing a baby doll). Families are always welcome to offer support during these moments but the joy of the demonstration model is that you can trust that I will step in if you’re not sure what to do or are curious about how I would intervene.  

Introverts Unite! 

“In the midst of a hectic life, peacefully watching their own and others’ children freely and joyfully exploring, with no agenda and no responsibility to make intelligent or witty conversation, especially among competitive types, is such a relief.” -Ruth Anne Hammond 

While silence can be uncomfortable for some, it can be vastly preferable to conversation for others. Offering a period of quiet respite honors the needs of tired parents, introverts, and neurodivergent folks. 

I know that sitting quietly can feel like a lot, especially when you’re exhausted or needing to be heard. I hope that these benefits will sweeten the practice until it becomes second nature for you (it will). In the meantime, I’m here to make sure you feel safe and supported on your unique parenting journey. 

Take good care, 

Laurel 

Once you learn how to observe, how to pay full attention, your relationship with other people, grown ups included, will also change. You give them a gift by telling them with your attentive behavior, ‘You are worth my interest and full attention.’ Every human being likes to be listened to, to get genuine attention, to feel understood, accepted, approved of and appreciated.
— Magda Gerber

References

Gerber, M. (2003). Dear parent: Caring for infants with respect. Resources for Infant Educarers (RIE).

Hammond, R. A. (2019). Respecting babies: A guide to Educaring® for parents and professionals. Zero to three.

Naumburg, C. (2019). How to stop losing your sh*t with your kids: A practical guide to becoming a Calmer, happier parent. Workman Publishing.

6 Ways Anxiety Can Show Up in a Parent-Child Class

(5 min. read) I’m going to self-disclose here. I struggle with anxiety (including social anxiety) and have for most of my life. It isn’t always predictable as to when it will pop up or how intense it will be. It can be frustrating and discouraging… so often I just want to feel calm and effortlessly connected and stop the endless swirl of thoughts, worries, and planning. It often takes a good amount of self-reg to get there but I’ve worked up to the point of being able to show up in social situations and remain connected (even if I’m not feeling super relaxed about it). The value of connection is greater to me than the discomfort of anxiety.

If anxiety is something you’re working with, know that I can relate.

I probably don’t have to tell you this but anxiety in the general population has been on the rise for decades and with the pandemic reached historic highs–both for children and parents.

“During the COVID-19 pandemic, nearly one in six children aged 5–17 years had daily or weekly symptoms of anxiety or depression, a significant increase from before the COVID-pandemic (16.7% versus 14.4%).”
— Zablotsky, et al., 2022

According to the folks over at Georgetown University’s Health Policy Institute, “Parents and caregivers also experienced greater mental health needs. In 2020, just two-thirds of caregivers reported being in “excellent or very good” mental health, and just 6 in 10 reported coping “very well” with the demands of childrearing, both down significantly compared to 2016. On the other hand, 1 in 12 kids lived with someone with a mental illness in 2020, a 5.5 percent increase compared to 2016.” (1) [Honestly, was anyone in “excellent or very good” mental health during 2020??]

The more time I spend in these classes with families the more I’ve had time to consider the ways anxiety can manifest. A recent podcast episode with Dr. Sarah Bren and conversation with a local perinatal psychotherapist both reinforced my intuition about what’s going on with parents right now (hint: anxiety, especially social anxiety).

Here are a few of the ways anxiety can show up in a parent-child class:

  1. Anxiety about my child’s behavior

  • Is my child’s behavior “normal?” Is my child’s behavior typical for their age? Are they developing differently than other children? Are they on-target for their developmental milestones?

  • What if other parents are judging my child?

    To these first two points I will say: developmentally appropriate behavior is expected in class–crying, fussing, quibbles about toys, frustrations about sharing space, demands and tantrums from toddlers… it’s all normal and it’s all welcome here. Children are offered direct support with managing their impulses and frustrations—I make sure everyone stays safe—but all feelings are welcome, normalized, and valued (for both children and parents).

  • My child is exploring the Pikler triangle, climbing the ramp, or moving in a bold and experimental way… I’m worried about them!

Generally parents have very limited access to safe, social spaces where they can truly relax about what their child is and isn’t doing (especially in regards to social learning)—I want this space to be characterized by an atmosphere of welcoming acceptance.

2. Anxiety about my responses to my child’s behavior (aka public parenting)

  • What if the other parents are judging me?

  • Am I doing enough? Am I doing it “right?” Am I intervening too much? Am I saying the “right” things? I’m not sure what to do…

  • I don’t feel like I can respond as my best self when I’m worried about others watching me

3. My own social anxiety

  • What if people are judging me (or my parenting choices)? What if I’m doing things differently than everyone else? What if my child’s behavior reflects poorly on my parenting?

  • What if my voice trembles or I blush? What if they notice that I’m anxious?

  • What will I say about my week? If someone asks for advice or support? What if my mind goes blank?

  • It can be frightening to be seen/witnessed and to be vulnerable

  • Fretting about something I said during class long after class is over

4. Being-together-again anxiety (my own) [specific to this moment in time emergence from COVID]

  • Fears of contagion (COVID, RSV, flu…): What if my child gets sick? What if I get sick? What if my child gets another child sick? Did someone cough? Sneeze?

  • We’re all a bit out of practice (it’s perhaps more comfortable to stay at home)

A toddler hides their face in an adult's legs. The adult is standing and wearing jeans.

Photo by ABDALLA M on Unsplash

5. Caution about being together (my child’s) [this can range from typical, developmentally appropriate caution to clinically significant anxiety that disrupts my child’s ability to participate in life]

  • Being in an unfamiliar place, with unfamiliar people (may ask to leave, may want to stick close to their parent, sit on their lap, or be held)

  • Not having had many opportunities to play with peers due to the pandemic

  • What may present as a child’s anxiety may actually be them picking up on our anxious cues. Children are exquisitely attuned to our emotional state and can pick up on subtle tension, shallow/faster breathing, and other cues signaling to them that the environment isn’t safe. It’s always our job to regulate ourselves first and communicate through our tone and body language that social interactions can be safe and enjoyable!

6. Sitting still and quietly observing

  • This can feel like anxiety when we’re used to perpetual movement or busyness (or can allow space to feel anxiety that was there all along but covered up)

  • Silence can be uncomfortable!

  • Is there any other time throughout the week when we sit still with our child for an hour and a half? Probably not! It makes sense that it’s going to feel hard at first. Your tolerance will grow with time and patience, much as your child’s capacity for independent play grows.

A person wearing a t-shirt that says "your anxiety is lying to you!" is taking a photo of an open-air structure with an ornate roof

Photo by Jayy Torres on Unsplash

What to do?

  • Get some exercise in the morning before class if you’re able

  • Breathe! (never underestimate the value of directing our attention to the breath for a few cycles)

  • Try a grounding technique

  • Notice “the story I’m telling myself”

  • Take a break from class if you need to–go walk the labyrinth, grab some tea at the cafe, sit in the sanctuary, splash some cold water on your face in the bathroom

  • Offer yourself some kind words (“I feel uncomfortable but I can handle this. Getting support is really important for my mental health.”)

I’ve found that the parents who sign up for these classes are incredibly gentle, patient, and supportive of one another. It’s also my role as a facilitator to support the cultivation of a safe space. And usually with time comes greater comfort and ease. If you’re struggling with anxiety and want to know more about the ways I can support you in class (or have something to add to this list), send me an email!

Take good care,

Laurel

 

Music Class Won’t Make Your Life Easier… but RIE Class Might

(2 min read) A popular music class for infants and toddlers overlaps with our parent-toddler class and I get an opportunity to overhear (and sometimes observe) what goes on in that class. While this post is not intended to disparage this class, or music classes in general (music is one of my great loves), I’ve observed some crucial differences in the way parents and children participate in the music class versus in a RIE-inspired class. Participating in a music class is one more thing to do. Parents and carers chase children around, they lift and wiggle babies’ bodies, recorded music is sometimes played at a volume I find to be overstimulating (and I’m an adult, sitting inside a building, quite a distance away). Many babies look stunned, confused, or skeptical. There aren’t many opportunities for parents to chat with one another, let alone dive into deep discussions. Nobody seems to be particularly relaxed. Honestly, it sounds kind of exhausting. 

In this type of class there is no space for the child’s agenda, for the child to decide what they’ll do or what they’re interested in on a given day. They’re along for the ride. Very few classes that I’ve ever attended with infants or toddlers (be it pre-pandemic in-person story time, toddler gymnastics, or something similar) have been conducted at a slow-enough pace to align well with the pace of a young child or demonstrated a developmentally-appropriate awareness of the number and frequency of transitions in their class rhythm. 

Infant on hands and knees on floor with adult sitting on floor behind, smiling

Photo by Kevin Gent on Unsplash

In a RIE-inspired class, you choose a floor chair where your body will be well-supported and you sit down. Sure, if your kiddo is mobile you may choose to spot them as they explore the Pikler triangle or approach another child’s face but I–as the facilitator–am also there to offer support, spotting, and selective intervention in those instances. Parents and carers of pre-mobile kiddos may get up to change a diaper or feed a child at their seat but aside from that they get the opportunity to slow down, in community, to the pace of an infant.

Families have an opportunity to experience an hour of calm, acceptance, support, validation, and slowness, where forced sharing, “being nice,” and other developmentally inappropriate (but extremely common and well-intentioned) expectations are left at the door.  

Photo by Yan Krukov from Pexels

While the classes can be meaningful and transformational on their own, their value is that they are a microcosm of Magda Gerber’s approach to respectful caregiving. Her approach emphasizes: 

  • Slowing down 

  • Observation and awareness of the strengths and capabilities of young children 

  • Balancing the needs of parents/carers and children 

  • Trusting that infants and toddlers have their own ideas and can be fully responsible for their own play 

  • That it is our responsibility to attune to and communicate with children but it is not our responsibility to “fix” their feelings (learning our roles and our children’s roles) 

  • A culture of support, gentle curiosity, and flexibility (Magda was known to respond frequently to questions with the phrase, “It depends”) 

  • And so much more

I hear variations of the same theme over and over from different families:

“I honestly don’t know what I would do without this approach.” 

These families find the experience of caring for children to be manageable, balanced, and enjoyable because there is a framework from which to operate. This approach requires an investment, as do all relationships and almost anything worthwhile but I think you’ll discover that the investment will be worth your while as it plays out in your relationship with your child. 

These classes provide a place where you can your child can simply *be,* where you and your child will be welcomed wholeheartedly, where you can share and investigate your experiences, questions, and stories in a gentle, kind, and supportive community of folks who are also learning about and practicing respectful caregiving… oh yeah, and it might also make your life a little easier. 

Note: While I am a RIE® Intern and in the final phase of my professional development with RIE®, the classes I offer are “RIE-Inspired” (not RIE® Certified Parent-Infant Guidance classes) because I have not yet completed my training. My classes closely resemble certified classes in their rhythm and physical environment.